Thursday, January 28, 2021

My Challenge To Catholic Men's Societies

Last Saturday I posted about the sacrilegious attack on Holy Mass in Columbus Ohio, and the pathetic reaction to the thugs by the Mass attendees.  It appears that the men in that contingent simply allowed the thugs to run riot through the Church.  They were stopped only by the police; who knows how long it took them to arrive?

It dawned on me today that there are several Catholic men's organizations operating today.  Do any of them deal with these kinds of matters?  Are they contemplating any strategies?  I speak not only of the Knights of Columbus, but also newer ones such as That Man Is You and Exodus 90.

I looked at their websites just now and saw no signs of them even paying attention to such attacks - attacks that will only increase, given the current political climate that is our new reality.  They seem to be focused on personal holiness and family life, but that's it.  Ostensibly they are about promoting authentic Catholic manhood, but being an authentic Catholic also entails paying attention and addressing the spiritual and moral ills that plague society at large.  Last Saturday we had a case of those spiritually malevolent forces literally barging into our Churches.  How long will it be until they cause upheaval in your parish Mass, or even barge into your homes?  That will happen if they perceive passivity on our parts  - the men in particular.

In Spring of 2019, pro-abortion Mark Shriver gave the commencement address at Mount St Mary's in Emmitsburg MD.  I tried desperately to get a group of Catholics who would give a few hours of their Saturday morning to picket that mess.  I approached some men in my parish, but they excused themselves by saying that their TMIY chapter was going to watch one of their movies and discuss it afterwards.  I said nothing, but the irony struck me.  Here they were, choosing to talk about Catholic manhood while passing up an opportunity to actually do Catholic manhood.  I am not belittling the need for Catholic men to gather for fellowship, but I do question the reluctance to join a once-in-a-while opportunity to put their skin in the game, as it were.

As you saw in the linked post, I was not alone.  A group of young men from the American Society for the Defense of Tradition Family and Property were there.  These men are often out in the streets, confronting evil as they see it; I've been privileged to join them at Georgetown University, too.

In all of this discussion about Catholic manhood, has there ever been discussion or even a thought about the responsibility to defend against unjust aggression?  That is a responsibility particularly incumbent upon fathers and men.  Are these groups going to broach matters such as:

  • De-escalation skills
  • Crowd-control techniques
  • Restraining aggressive individual
  • Martial arts
  • Weapons usage
My hope and prayer is that this episode in Ohio can serve as a "wake-up" call so that Catholic men will actually take up their mantle, even if it involves rancor and even danger.  Some persecutions can be staved simply by standing up to aggressors in a firm manner.


  1. Couldn't agree more. My wife and I offered to go to Mass armed and the pastor said, "we should all be ready to die for Christ, not kill for Christ." He did end up saying he wouldn't kick us out if we were armed, so let's just say we are still going to Mass. The TFP guys are some of the only men willing to suffer the scorn and humiliation and stand up to the foaming-at-the-mouth little possessed snowflakes out there. God bless them and you!

  2. Thank you for excellent analysis. I carry & don’t ask the priest. He’s likely not going to support one who actually protects The Eucharist, him, his other parishioners. Outside of the TLM the priests & bishops have pansified Catholic men for decades. Now we are here. The KCs have been turned into an insurance selling breakfast making crew. My experience with Cursio years ago was TERRIBLE! They get gooey & try to make every man cry like a school girl. What do we expect with these sappy programs??? Cockle doodle doo??? No wonder men have left the Church in droves. What about their sons. And now top brass have given green light officially to pantsuit females on altar??? The homos & trannies are being welcomed by bishops. Where does anyone think this is going to help men & families come back to The Church? I went to a men’s group new parish last year. 2 meetings- the pastor did not show up either night. No apology about him NOT making it. The men were glad handing, but I can’t say I saw real manly Catholic Christian men there for the most part. At the very least, the few remaining REAL men coming to Mass should have pepper spray- best is the Kimber 2 shot device. It might disarm or confuse an attacker long enough to at least save your wife, family & the priest. We know from the Columbus incident, the bishop will stop The Mass & run & hide.

  3. "We should all be ready to die for Christ." What he really meant to say was "We should all be ready to watch other people be murdered and do nothing about it to save their lives, because otherwise you might have someone saying mean things to you like ' You're killing for Christ!" Can't have that! Must save our "holy" reputations!" What a Colossal LOSER this priest is!

  4. I had the same reaction to the wimpy men attending that Mass. Good to see it in print here.


Please be respectful and courteous to others on this blog. We reserve the right to delete comments that violate courtesy and/or those that promote dissent from the Magisterium of the Roman Catholic Church.